A few weeks ago, one of our local ladies had expressed interest to me in learning how to spin, and I gave her my normal caveat, "My method isn't really the way most other SCAdian spinsters do it." It's definitely an
unorthodox method--a worsted technique rather than the more-common woollen. Her response was, "Well, if it works, who cares, right?"
I'd had a run-in a few years ago, back when I used to play in Æthelmearc, with a couple ladies who expressed negativity about my technique. It's made me rather shy about teaching others to do it my way.
Someone cares, evidently.
But armed with new-found curiosity inspired by herself, this afternoon I set out to figure out the "orthodox" way to do it. (I'm sure this was aided by having a poof of waste fibre carded for me by students at the demo yesterday with which to experiment.) It took me about 5 minutes to figure out, and I worked with it for a couple hours, just to practice and compare.
Really, I can't say there are any apparent advantages over my "unorthodox" technique: I perceived no difference in speed or the number of slubs. I did notice that I wasn't able to get quite the draft length with the "orthodox" technique--5 or 6 cm as opposed to my normal 10--but I did wind the spindle a little less frequently. Rather frustratingly, I did notice a much greater frequency in draft breakage, that infuriating moment when the yarn snaps at the unspun part, dropping your spindle to the floor trailing a wisp of un-spinning fibre when some smartass invariably quips, "So is that why they call it a drop spindle?", but that may just be my lack of practice or Mercury being in retrograde or whatever. There's a little more fuzz to the surface of the woollen technique, but I can't overall say there's much visible difference to the finished product. Haven't yet tested the difference in tensile strength between the two techniques, but I do know that worsted wool is better for warp when weaving.
Trying this new-to-me technique
did have the advantage of showing me that I control the fibre much more with my left hand than my right; I had to switch hands in order to wind the spindle in my right hand, rather than my normal easy transition from spinning to winding.
Overall estimation: why shouldn't spinsters have options as to technique? I'll be fine teaching one-on-one.